PDA

View Full Version : Black Powder Primer


411man
02-15-2010, 07:19 PM
Black Powder Primer


It is hoped that this will serve as a basic source of information on Black Powder.


History of Black Powder

http://www.angelfire.com/home/oldgun...ack_powder.htm


BLACK POWDER

If you are going to shoot black powder guns you really need to know what black powder is, how to select the right black powder for you gun, and understand the differences between real black powder and the black powder substitutes that are now available.

The History

No one knows exactly when black powder was discovered but credit is normally given to the Chinese who were experimenting with explosives at least 200 years before Christ. Originally these explosives were used in ceremonies and rituals, until someone got the bright idea of shoving them down a tube and packing stone and other junk on top of it. Thus the cannon was born. It would be centuries before a flintlock rifle would evolve from these early hand cannons, and still another couple of centuries after that before the modern day firearm and smokeless powder would make their debut.

In 1252, credit is given to Roger Bacon for first documenting the formula for black powder. The Monk, Bacon, correctly identified the explosive nature of a sulfur, carbon, and potassium nitrate mix. Bacon may have been the first to write down the recipe, but historians believe that much of Europe and Asia were all using forms of black powder by well before this time.

Black Powder Today

Black powder today is still produced in a fashion similar to production methods of old. Powdered sulfur, carbon, and potassium nitrate (saltpeter) are mixed with water and denatured alcohol, the mixture is then pressed into large cakes to dry. The water and alcohol are used to prevent the powder from igniting, and help produce a much more uniform mixture. After drying the cakes are broken down into small granules. These granules are then sorted according to size, and sold to consumers.

Granular size of the powder determines the intended use of the powder. Black powder granules come in sizes from the largest grain 1fg (fg) down to the very finest 4fg (ffffg).

The sizes are all suited for a particular type of use:

1fg: This powder has the largest grains and normally is not used in firearms, but if you happen to have a cannon, this just might be the powder for you.

2fg: The actual grain size of the powder is smaller than that of the 1fg powder. This powder is most commonly used in larger bored rifles starting at about .45 caliber and up.

3fg: This powder has an even finer grain and is used primarily in pistols and small bore rifles of up to .54 caliber.

Note there is some overlap between the uses of 2fg and 3fg. My personal preference, and I make no claims that it will work for everyone, is 3fg powder in pistols and all my rifles up to .50 cal, and use 2fg in all larger calibers.

4fg: This is the finest powder and is usually reserved for use in the flash pan on flintlock rifles.

Armed with the above information the novice may feel reasonably confident in walking into you local muzzleloader supplier and selecting a tin of powder. Until they realize that a lot of places don’t stock real black powder, and a black powder substitute is necessary. The biggest reason for this is that the good ol’ US of A classifies real black powder, as an explosive and retailers must have special permits to stock it. While the substitutes are all classified as propellant and are don’t fall under the same restrictions as real black powder.

The Substitutes

So what options are available? First black powder may be hard to find, but not impossible. If you want to shoot the real stuff, check around, odds are somebody will stock it. Second, on the market today there are black powder substitutes, which are designed to be used in place of real black powder. The three most common substitutes are Pyrodex, Clean Shot, and Clear Shot, with Pyrodex being the most common.

Pyrodex as been on the market for years and really is a hybrid black powder. It produces less foulings (the junk left in your barrel after shooting black powder), than real black powder, and delivers roughly the same energy for a given load. While it does produce less foulings than black powder – it still produces it fair share, and the foulings are corrosive, so cleaning your gun is mandatory after firing.

Before going any farther let me make something very clear. All of the black powder substitutes are classified as propellants or smokeless powders. This is only a government hazardous material classification, and these powders do not function the same as smokeless powders. What this means is: NEVER USE NITRO BASED (SMOKELESS POWDERS) IN A MUZZLELOADER! NEVER MIX SMOKELESS POWDERS WITH BLACK POWDER OR THE BLACK POWDER SUBSTITUTES. If you decide to ignore this warning take a nice long look at your hands and fingers, because you may never see them again, if you are really unlucky you may never see anything again except for the roots of the lilies you’ll be pushing up.

Clean Shot and Clear Shot are the latest substitutes to hit the market. Though they have similar names and make similar claims, two separate and unrelated companies make them. Both are e a volumetric substitute for black powder, but do not produce the huge amounts of corrosive fouling common with black powder and Pyrodex. Both of these products are fairly new to the black powder scene and while there is no doubt that they produce less foulings and the fouling are not as corrosive, the jury is still out concerning their performance. Some people swear by them, others swear at them. These two powders can be a bit hard to locate, it seems neither company’s production is keeping up with demand (as of June 2001). I don’t believe this to be a long term problem, interest in their product is too great. Both of these powders will cost you a bit more than real black or Pyrodex, but may be worth it when the reduced clean up and potential corrosion is considered.

Which is the best of the four? I will only say that for traditional styled sidelock muzzleloaders I prefer real black powder. Real black powder requires less energy to ignite, and this can be an advantage in traditional guns because they typically deliver less energy from the cap or flash pan then do the modern day in-lines. For all other cases I think the powder you use is personal choice, with performance, cost, clean up and authenticity all being factors.

A new trend is to offer the substitutes in a palletized form that match the gun’s bore. Pellets are gaining popularity among hunters concerned with fast reloads. Pellets are harder to ignite then loose powder and should only be used in in-lines. The only advantage I see with pellets is their convenience makes for faster loading. I personally don’t use them for the following reasons:

1- Cost, grain for grain they cost more than loose powder. If I need speed I’ll use a quick-loader

2-Usability, if you shoot multiple black powder calibers you have to buy the different sized pellets for each one.

3-Reliabiliaty, pellets are harder to ignite than loose powder, increasing the chance of misfires and hangfires.

4-Vesitility, what happens when your gun decides it likes a load that can't be chopped up into 30 or 50-grain increments?

That said I know there are numerous people who use and love pellets and if you are inclined to use them I wish you the best of luck, I know many BP shooters love them.

Measuring Black Powder

Black powder is measured by volume not weight, and the substitutes are all designed to produce equal energy for a given volume. Do not weigh black powder and then use an equivalent weight of any of the substitutes. The substitutes are not designed to weigh the same as black powder. Bottom line, if you use a volumetric measure you should get roughly equal performance from equal loads regardless of which powder you are shooting.

If shooting real black powder or Pyrodex foulings will build up, and you may need to run a cleaning patch down the barrel every 3rd or 5th shot. This fouling is corrosive and must be cleaned out after shooting. Clean Shot and Clear Shot claim the foulings produced is not corrosive, but both still recommend cleaning when done shooting. All four powders’ foulings will clean up with hot soapy water. Many shooters like to use a solvent after water, but this is not required. After cleaning, lightly oil the barrel and other metal parts.

Swiss Black Powder

A final note, a new “sporting grade” powder sold as Swiss Powder has been getting a lot of great press. Swiss powder is a high-grade black powder that burns cleaner than most black powders. It still produces the same corrosive foulings of regular black powder (albeit less), so cleaning is still a must. Swiss Powder, because it is more efficient, produces more energy, and it is recommend that starting loads be cut by about 10% from your typical black powder load.

There you have it, everything you need to know about black powder – I didn’t say everything there is to know, but with the information contained above you should be able to make an intelligent choice when choosing between the black powder you are going to shoot. Be safe, and always follow the gun manufacturer’s recommended loading and shooting procedures.







What is Black Powder?

http://www.pyroguide.com/index.php?title=Black_powder

Black powder is a chemical compound invented in the 9th century and was practically the only known propellant and explosive until the middle of the 19th century. As such it has been superseded by more efficient explosives such as smokeless powders and TNT. It is still manufactured today although primarly used in fireworks, model rocket engines, and in reproductions of muzzleloading weapons. Black powder is commonly referred to as being the backbone of all fireworks, a statement which indeed comes near to the truth.

The optimum proportions for black powder are: 74.64% Potassium nitrate, 13.51% charcoal, and 11.85% sulfur. The current standard for black powder manufactured by pyrotechnicians today is 75% potassium nitrate, 15% charcoal and 10% sulfur

Manufacture

Generally commercial manufacturers (such as GOEX) make use of large and heavy wheel mills to integrate the components as well as possible. While such machinery is beyond the means of most amateur pyros, comparable products can be made at home. The most common methods of small scale black powder manufacture are treated and compared here: Black Powder Manufacture.

The performance of black powder is contingent on many factors, the two most important being method of manufacture (intimacy of integration) and derivation of charcoal (type of wood, carbonisation process).

Black powder is used "corned" (granulated) when it is expected to provide a high amount of force in a short period of time e.g. for propelling or breaking shells etc. The intimately mixed powder (meal powder) is granulated either via dampening and rubbing through a coarse screen ("ricing") or via dampening, pressing to a known density (usually about 1,7g/ccm) and crushing the resulting "cakes" ("corning"). Commercial grain gunpowder is granulated using the latter method. The resulting material is separated by size using screens.



Regulation

Black powder is classified as a low explosive, that is, it deflagrates (burns) rapidly. High explosives detonate at a rate approximately 10 times faster than the burning of black powder.

Although black powder is not a high explosive, the United States Department of Transportation classifies it as a "Class A High Explosive" for shipment because it is so easily ignited. Highly destructive explosions at fireworks manufacturing plants are rather common events, especially in Asia. Complete manufactured devices containing black powder are usually classified as "Class C Firework", "Class C Model Rocket Engine", etc. for shipment because they are harder to ignite than the loose powder.





http://kcsurvival.lefora.com/2008/11/16/black-powder/



Black Powder, also known as Gunpowder, is an explosive that has been around, literally, for centuries. The exact origins of the formula are lost in time, but it is known that the Chinese used Black Powder in weaponry at least 1,000 years ago. Technically, Black Powder burns by a process known as deflagration. This differs from detonation in that Black Powder produces subsonic shock waves, as opposed to the supersonic shock waves produced by explosives such as Dynamite, C-4 or TNT. This means that Black Powder is better suited as a propellant (such as in fireworks, bullets and cannons) than blasting (such as in construction or demolition).

Safety
Black Powder is dangerous! The powder burns at a very high temperature, and is easily ignited. (High grade powder doesn't even need a flame to ignite - it can be set off by percussion, such as the firing pin of a pistol.) Basically, what I am saying is that if you are not careful, you could land up with very severe burns, or worse. Some basic guidelines to follow:

Always mix ingredients in small amounts. Do not try to make 10 Kg of black powder (or any explosive) in one batch. Mixing small amounts of powder limits the potential damage should an unexpected explosion occur.
Keep your workplace tidy. Always carefully clean up spilled chemicals. Some materials can spontaneously combust when mixed (this is especially true of nitrates and chlorates). For the same reason, use separate instruments (plastic spoons, mixing cups, etc) for different chemicals. Label your instruments so that you know what materials they have been in contact with.
Mix materials outdoors. Chemical explosives contain their own internal source of oxygen, and cannot be smothered. If you start a chemical fire indoors, it can be nearly impossible to extinguish.
Be aware of static sparks. Do not use metal instruments to mix or grind materials. Do not store chemicals in metal containers. Use ceramics or plastics wherever possible. Store chemicals and mixtures in plastic containers or ZipLoc. bags.
Wear safety goggles. Should the worst happen, skin can be grafted. Eyes cannot be replaced.
Ingredients
Black Powder has traditionally consisted of three ingredients: Potassium Nitrate (KNO3, also known as Salt Peter), Sulfur and Charcoal. The Sulfur and Charcoal provide fuel for the reaction, while the Potassium Nitrate provides Oxygen. By themselves, Charcoal and Sulfur will burn, albeit very slowly. The addition of an oxidizer (such as KNO3) greatly speeds up the burn rate of the fuel, resulting in an explosive reaction.

The traditional ratio of the ingredients is 15:3:2 of KNO3, Charcoal and Sulfur by weight (not volume!). However, simply mixing the dry ingredients together will not give you black powder. At best, you will get a green powder that will do little more than produce vast quantities of smoke, and annoy your neighbors. In order to make high-grade powder, a little work is needed.

Preparing the Ingredients
The quality of the resulting powder depends on a number of factors. The most important of these is binding, which refers to how tightly the KNO3 is mixed in with the Charcoal/Sulfur mixture. This is why a loose binding, such as a dry mix, produces a very low-grade powder.

The quality of the powder is defined by its burn rate, usually expressed in cm3/s. A burn rate of about 14 cm3/s or higher is required to use the powder as a propellant. (Also, possession and manufacture of powder with a burn rate of 14 cm3/s or higher constitutes a weapons violation under US law, unless you are also in possession of an ATF license.)

I will present two methods of preparing black powder here. The first produces powder with a slightly lower burn rate, but is safer to prepare. The second can produce very high quality powder, but contains an element of danger. The methods presented here will get you a burn rate of 14 cm3/s or better, depending on how much patience you have, and the quality of your ingredients.

The Charcoal/Sulfur mixture must be ground as finely as possible. Simply whacking away at your barbeque charcoal with a hammer is not going to cut it. The charcoal must be ground into a very fine powder. Commercial manufacturers use large machines known as ball mills to crush the charcoal and sulfur. A ball mill is basically a large rotating drum filled with charcoal, sulfur and a crushing agent, such as lead balls or heavy stones. The mill is rotated at high speed for up to 48 hours or longer. The result is a very finely powdered charcoal/sulfur mixture. (Note: for reasons which should be very obvious, the Potassium Nitrate is not mixed in with the fuel during the milling stage, unless you want to be picking bits of your ball mill out of the walls of your factory.)

Ball Mills are very expensive, and it is unlikely that the average hobbyist will be able to afford one. There are alternatives, however. One is to simply buy the charcoal in a powdered form. There are several mail order companies that will provide powdered charcoal. (See the list of suppliers at the end of this article). The other alternative is to fashion a ball mill of your own, if you happen to be a handyman. Or, you could simply buy a cheap gem-polishing toy mill from your local Wal-Mart, and use kids marbles, or heavy decorative stones as a crushing agent. You will have to run the mill continuously for at least 72 hours with this method, however. Assuming that you have a powdered charcoal/sulfur mixture in the right quantities, how do you get the KNO3 to bind to the mixture? The solution is to employ a useful property of Potassium Nitrate - it is soluble in water. Charcoal and sulfur, on the other hand, are not soluble in water. They will, however, absorb KNO3 from water under suitable circumstances. The addition of cold alcohol to the mix will have the effect of suddenly leaching the water out of the mixture, leaving just the salt behind, hopefully tightly bound to the fuel.

Method 1 - Boiling
Requirements:

Skillet, stovetop (preferably outdoors!), plastic strirrer, 750 ml of Isopropyl Alcohol, household sieves, coffee filters.

The recipe for producing black powder using this method is as follows (adjust quantities as desired, but remember to stick to the ratio). Before you start, have a 750 ml bottle of rubbing alcohol chilled in a freezer for at least 24 hours. (You can purchase rubbing alcohol, also known as Isopropyl Alcohol, from most any drugstore or supermarket).

Mix 30 grams of powdered charcoal with 20 grams of powdered sulfur, as described above.
Using a deep skillet, bring about three or four cups of water to boil. Stir in 150 grams of KNO3. Keep stirring until the Potassium Nitrate is completely dissolved. Add water as necessary, but try not to over-water the mixture.
Slowly sift in the charcoal/sulfur mixture. The mixture will tend to float on top of the water, so you will have to agitate the slush with a spoon or a whisk. Keep stirring until you get a wet, grayish sludge. This could take a while, so take your time and be careful. Don't let any of the mixture slop out of the skillet onto the hot stove-top, or you will most likely start a fire.
Once the sludge is uniformly mixed, remove the skillet from the stove. Pour in the chilled alcohol, and stir. Keep pouring and stirring until the sludge is cool enough to touch.
Pour the sludge into a coffee filter placed in a sieve over a plastic container. Allow the water/alcohol to drain out until the sludge is dry enough to leave an impression when you press into it.
Using a fine sieve, press the sludge through the sieve onto a large piece of cardboard or blotting paper. This should produce fine granules of powder. Take your time, evenly spreading the granules onto the paper or cardboard.
Allow the granules to dry in direct sunlight for at least 24 hours. When dry, pour the granules through a finer sieve to remove any fine powder from the granules. This fine powder (known as meal powder) is not useful for firecrackers or propellants, but can be used to make fuses or fountains.
You should now have real, honest-to-goodness Black Powder. Congrats.

Method 2 - Agitation
This method is very similar to that described above, but differs in the manner in which the ingredients are mixed. Because it uses electrical equipment, it is considerably more dangerous than the previous method, but can produce very high quality powder.

Requirements:

Electric kitchen blender, 750 ml of Isopropyl Alcohol, household sieve, coffee filters.

Pour 3 or 4 cups of boiling water into the blender. Slowly add 150 grams of KNO3. Cover the blender, and agitate at medium speed for about ten minutes. (Note - it is advisable to use an extension cord to start the blender from a safe distance. Again, this should be done outdoors!)
Slowly mix in 50 grams of charcoal/sulfur mixture. This should be done by turning off the blender, pouring in a small amount of the mixture, restarting the blender and mixing until the charcoal/sulfur is completely wet. Repeat until all the fuel has been added and thoroughly mixed. (Take your time - remember: haste kills!)
Let the blender run at high speed for about 15 minutes. Slowly pour in the alcohol while the blender is running. You should hear the blender slow down as the mixture solidifies. Add more alcohol until the mixture is cool to the touch.
Follow steps 5 through 7 from method 1.

Testing Your Powder
In order to test the burn rate of your powder, all you need is a stopwatch and a soda can. Thanks to the magic of the metric system, it turns out that 1 ml = 1 cm3. Soda cans are usually marked with the volume in ml (the average can is 340 ml). You may not want to use an entire can, however, as that would be a waste. Most supermarkets sell soda in halfsize cans (such as you usually get on airliners). Or, you could simply cut a full sized can using a pair of metal shears, and calculate the volume of the can. (For those of you who slept through math at high school, the formula is v = h*pi*r2. Remember to use metric units. In other words, measure the height and diameter of the can in centimeters, not inches, miles or furlongs, or whatever else you Yanks have got stuck with.)

Now, fill the can to the brim with powder. Do not cover the can! One word - shrapnel! Insert a fuse (you can usually buy so-called "safety fuses" from a supermarket around the 4th of July, or New Years. Also, fireworks retailers almost always carry lengths of safety fuse. If you are desperate, simply insert a match into the can, with the match-head just under the surface of the powder.) Light the fuse, wait for the powder to start burning, and time the burn with the stopwatch. Divide the volume of powder by the time it takes to burn completely, and you have your burn rate.

411man
02-15-2010, 07:21 PM
Part 2

Part 2

Differences between Black Powder, substitutes, and Smokeless powder.

http://www.chuckhawks.com/difference_black_powders.htm



What is the Difference between Black, Pyrodex, Triple Seven, and Smokeless Powders?

By Randy Wakeman




That is a question that often comes up at this time of year, and understandably so. Though classified by the DOT as smokeless propellants, most muzzleloaders can be safely fired with black powder, Pyrodex, Triple Seven, Black Mag3, Pyrodex pellets, and Triple Seven Pellets. Only the Savage 10ML-II was designed to be used with all of these propellants, just like other muzzleloaders, plus certain recommended nitrocellulose (smokeless) powders. Smokeless powders are non-corrosive, offer less recoil, and leave very little residue. Here is a quick look at the basics.

Black powder is an old propellant, formed from a blend of natural ingredients: sulfur, potassium nitrate, and charcoal. Classified as an explosive, few muzzleloaders use true black powder these days because of limited availability. The energy produced by black powder in small arms use varies by manufacturer. "Swiss" black powder, for example, is considered a hotter propellant than "Goex" brand.

Black powder, Pyrodex, Black Mag3, and Triple Seven loose powder are all in the category of deflagrating powders. "Deflagrating" is just a fancy way of saying "fast-burning." These powders burn just as fast as they can as long as they can. Their grain size controls the burn rate. FFFF black powder is very, very easy to ignite; that is why the common application is as pan powder for flintlocks. FFF black powder is used often in .45 caliber or smaller bore muzzleloaders and sidelocks, FF is the standard for .50 caliber inline muzzleloaders. The "F" designation is just the screen size used in manufacture and the resultant grain size (coarseness).

In black powder the fuel is carbon; we are just burning charcoal. Black powder is horribly inefficient, as only about 50% of its mass turns into gas. The rest is solid residue that is forced out the muzzle as white smoke or left in the bore as corrosive fouling crud.

Pyrodex is the most common "black powder substitute." It is really the only synthetic black powder "performance" substitute in common use. By performance substitute, I refer to a charge of loose powder measure by volume. A 100 grain volumetric charge of Pyrodex RS (Rifle/Shotgun) is very close in performance to Goex FFg black powder.

There are differences, though, and this is where things get a bit convoluted. Pyrodex is bulkier, another way of saying "less dense." By weight, it is more powerful than Goex black powder. But, the traditional method of measuring black powder is indeed by volume, so in that sense it is a black powder performance substitute.

By actual weight, it is not the same. 100 grains measured by volume of Goex FFg is about 101.3 grains by weight. 100 grains measured by volume of Pyrodex RS is about 72.5 grains by weight. Pyrodex is where confusion can start to set in, as the standard "F" designations of powder coarseness start to go out the window.

Pyrodex "Select," formulated for use in muzzleloading rifles, is touted as an "extremely consistent" grade of Pyrodex, and has the largest grain size of them all. It is even farther away from black powder by actual weight; 100 grains volumetric equals about 63.9 grains by actual weight.

Pyrodex, though man-made and with a variety of additives, still has sulfur in it and is corrosive. It is classified as a smokeless powder by the DOT, and bears little resemblance to traditional black powder in actual weight or grain size. It is a bit harder to ignite than black powder, and is safer to handle, use, and store due to this fact. It is also not as impact-sensitive as is true black powder. Pyrodex is not classified as an explosive as is black powder, and is sold at many chain stores due to this fact.

Triple Seven, Black Mag3, and Goex Clear Shot get us into an area where the muzzleloading industry has drifted into double-talk, sidestepping, and confusion. These propellants have nothing in common with true black powder at all; chemically, neither sulfur nor charcoal is present. They are still carbon-burning propellants, though, of the deflagrating (fast-burning) type. They are measured volumetrically, but only Goex Clear Shot can be considered a black powder performance substitute.

Triple Seven and Black Mag3 are far hotter (or more energetic) than good old black powder, and produce higher velocities and pressures. Still burning carbon, the carbon-based fuel burned here is from the sugar family, not from wood (charcoal). These propellants are actually far more modern than nitrocellulose based powders. Triple Seven and Black Mag3 only become available in the 21st Century.

Referring to Triple Seven and Black Mag3, the only thing that they have in common with black powder is they can be volumetrically measured with old black powder measures. They are not as corrosive as black powder (Black Mag3 claims to be non-corrosive), have little in common chemically, and produce more pressure, heat, and velocity than black powder. They are considered smokeless powder by the DOT, and should be used with caution in older muzzleloaders, as there is no way that 100 grains volumetric charge of Triple Seven or Black Mag3 can be considered "the same" as traditional black powder. They are still relatively inefficient propellants, leaving behind close to 50% of their mass as non-combusted, solid residue.

Referring to Triple Seven, that 50% unburned material is substantially less fouling than black powder for the simple reason that a 100 grain volumetric charge of Triple Seven, though it produces more energy than black powder, is far less by actual weight. More directly stated, you still have about 50% of the garbage left, but you start with less garbage to burn in the first place.

Pyrodex and Triple Seven pellets are the area where the snake oil sales pitch starts to sizzle. Sold as black powder equivalents of "pelletized powder," they have nothing to do with traditional black powder. The pelletized powder lingo is wishful thinking, as pellets are just pellets. This type of tortured language adds more confusion to the mix. If you take two tablets of aspirin and call me in the morning, you have taken two aspirin tablets, not "tabletized acetylsalicylic acid." Sometimes pellets are just pellets, ask any rabbit, and a cigar is just a cigar. Let's talk about what they really are, and what they do.

Pyrodex pellets are a sophisticated rocket fuel type propellant, more related to an Estes rocket engine than black powder. They consist of a black igniter portion on one side of the base; although called an "ignition accelerant," this is nothing more than good old black powder. They are, of course, not volumetrically measured, and they do not burn at all like loose powder. A Pyrodex pellet burns progressively down the bore, from the base in, from the outside in, and--due to the hole in the center--from the inside out.

Though not recommended by Hodgdon, most inline manufacturers currently allow and promote the use of "three pellet loads" for velocities far in excess of what loose black powder or Pyrodex can possibly achieve. How fast? One load out of the 2004 Knight catalog shows a muzzle velocity of 2417 fps, another is 2639 fps! These velocities can actually be bettered in a longer barreled gun, like the Thompson/Center Omega.

Triple Seven pellets, used in three-pellet configuration, actually produce a bit more muzzle velocity. Where Pyrodex pellets are pressed into shape from black powder and Pyrodex RS, Triple Seven pellets are made from straight Triple Seven, and are harder to ignite. For what it is worth, I've personally found Pyrodex pellet loads to be more consistent, and more accurate.

A word of caution is in order. Hodgdon does not condone the use of more than 100 grains of their Pyrodex or Triple Seven pellets in .45 or .50 caliber muzzleloaders, and they clearly, loudly proclaim that warning with every box of pellets sold. Several people have asked, "What pressures do three pellets produce?" Well, there is no finite answer. Much is necessarily contingent on projectile weight, type, and caliber of rifle.

I shoot a few flaming pellets into the air on the 4th of July. The kids get a kick out of it, but as there is no projectile there is little pressure. Lyman Ballistic Laboratories has published three Pyrodex pellet-powered saboted bullet loads that develop 27,000 psi out of a 22" test barrel; Triple Seven pellets can produce more pressure than that.

Not all inline muzzleloaders have been tested with Triple Seven pellets, and it is a matter of public record that the casual take "three pellets and call me in the morning" approach can lead to an immediate trip to the emergency room. There are a few makes and models of inline muzzleloaders that have been extensively tested with three pellet loads, and I'll mention them right here: current production Knight Disc Rifles, Thompson Omega and Encore rifles, and the Savage 10ML-II.

Smokeless Powder, the original black powder substitute, became commercially available in the last decade of the 19th Century. As you've read above, the path to "black powder substitutes" is a convoluted, twisty one. What is called a "black powder substitute" has very little to do with the actual and factual, and a lot more to do with who has what to sell.

Only the Savage 10ML-II has been proven safe with nitrocellulose based smokeless powder, as opposed to solid fuel or deflagrating style DOT classified smokeless black powder substitutes like Triple 7 or Black Mag3 mentioned above. Folks are a bit confused about smokeless powder use in the Savage 10ML-II, but not nearly as bewildered as they are about the black powder / pellet / synthetic black powder substitute mess already described.





There is a myth that "smokeless powder" means "high pressure." That statement is sheer nonsense, borne out of complete ignorance. Most all shotshells today, of course, are powered by nitrocellulose based smokeless powder. Shotshells are mentioned as the current plastic wads used in today's shotshell ammo serve the same function as a sabot in a muzzleloader, that being of taking up windage in the bore and providing an effective gas seal. Note that these pressures, all nitrocellulose smokeless powder generated, are but a fraction of the pressures generated in today's inline muzzleloaders.

For comparison, please note that Lyman Ballistic Laboratories independent data shows that just 100 grains of Pyrodex RS fired by a CCI #11 cap produces 22,600 PSI when pushing a saboted 240 grain Hornady XTP bullet through a 22" test barrel.

The Savage 10ML-II is the only significant muzzleloader on the market that can use all the black powder substitutes mentioned. It was designed to use nitrocellulose-based powders from its inception.

The benefits are easy enough for even me to understand: a propellant such as Accurate Arms 5744 is economical, non-corrosive, and extremely clean burning compared to all the other "substitutes" mentioned. It offers far less recoil for a given saboted projectile and muzzle velocity than does Pyrodex or Triple Seven powder or pellets.

Many people have asked me why that is. The reason is simple, and two fold.

First, deflagrating propellants burn as fast as they can as quick as they can, resulting in a very sharp jolt of a primary recoil pulse. Accurate Arms 5744 burns progressively, a far smoother pressure curve. This results in a push to the shoulder, rather than a punch.

Second, as we previously mentioned, roughly half of the carbon-based propellant mass is left behind as solid residue. This inert residue must necessarily be pushed out of the bore by gas. From a recoil standpoint, this solid unburned residue is considered part of the ejecta. Approximately half of the carbon-based powder charge can be added to the bullet and sabot weight to calculate free recoil. With Accurate Arms 5744, there is no such mass of fouling, as virtually all the propellant converts to gas. Therefore, there is much less weight of additional ejecta to push out the barrel, and less recoil as a result.

I'm taking the liberty of mentioning Accurate Arms 5744 smokeless powder for a reason. It is the favorite propellant of the inventor of the Savage 10ML-II, Henry Ball, and is currently my favorite as well. It actually has more things in common with black powder from a usage standpoint than do Pyrodex or Triple Seven pellets. It can easily be volumetrically measured with great accuracy. (Not using a black powder measure, but using a Lee 3.4 cc smokeless powder measure.) It also is a powder, not a solid fuel.

The smokeless powder myth of "high pressure" has been disproved, and the notion that smokeless powder cannot be volumetrically measured is also wrong. All commercial smokeless ammunition is loaded by volume, not by weight, and anyone that has ever seen or used any of the popular MEC shotshell reloading presses knows that the powder is dropped by volume, not by weight.

Richard Lee, of course, has known the convenience of smokeless powder volumetric loading for decades, and has made it available to the masses with his "Lee Dipper Set." Perhaps I am being a bit redundant, but I must mention again that the Savage 10ML-II is the only muzzleloader in which you can safely use Accurate Arms 5744, or any other smokeless powder.

The fracas over smokeless powder in muzzleloading is silly. Perhaps it is due to the hyperbole driven marketing of smokepoles, but "smokeless" absolutely does not mean any type of smokeless in the Savage, either, nor just any charge. There are only four powders approved by Savage Arms, as of this writing, for use in the 10ML-II. Do not be confused just because some 200 different nitrocellulose powders are currently available. You don't use just any smokeless powder in a shotshell or rifle cartridge application, either.

The message is simple: use propellants approved by a quality muzzleloading arms manufacturer and you'll have no problems, provided you follow the rules of good reloading practices. If you are a muzzleloader, let there be no mistake, you are a reloader. All the freedom and all the responsibility that goes with reloading goes with muzzleloading.

In conclusion I'll just mention what "black powder substitutes" I've had the best luck with during the testing of some fifty different muzzleloaders over the last couple of years alone. 100 grains of Triple 7 FFg by volume has more or less been my preferred load for most quality inlines to date, including Austin & Halleck, Knight, and Thompson rifles. Pyrodex pellets have shown themselves to be more accurate than their Triple 7 counterparts. The Savage 10ML-II does well with both Hodgdon products, but Accurate Arms 5744 has been an easy choice due to delightfully soft recoil, extreme accuracy, and no necessity for immediate maintenance.

Whatever your choice, Pyrodex, Black Mag3, Triple Seven, or smokeless powder (in the Savage 10ML-II only), just let your gun tell you what combination it likes. Hopefully, this article has shed a little light on what today's inline muzzleloading propellants are really all about.

Congratulate yourself! If you've hung in there this long with me you've demonstrated far more interest and caring about your sport than most would be bothered with, and I thank





http://www.shootnhunt.com/black_powder/index.html

A black powder substitute is a replacement for black powder used in muzzleloading and cartridge firearms. Black powder substitutes offer a number of advantages over black powder, primarily including reduced sensitivity, reduced fouling, and increased efficiency. Due to property insurance and federal transportation regulations, black powder substitutes also can be transported and stored in interstate commerce in the United States using smokeless powder regulations, instead of the much more restrictive black powder regulations. Because of this, black powder substitutes are thus becoming more commonly available than traditional black powder, which has largely vanished from the shelves of most retailers. The grain is the traditional measurement of the mass of bullets, gunpowder, and smokeless powder; it is the measure used by the balances used in handloading; bullets are measured in increments of one grain, gunpowder in increments of 0.1 grains. Pyrodex, and other black powder substitutes, are not measured directly in grains of mass, but, rather, by a volumetric measure equivalent to an equal grains of mass of black powder (i.e., gunpowder)) measured with a scale. That is, to measure a so-called "60 grain measurement" of Hodgdon's Pyrodex suitable for use in a muzzleloader rifle, one uses a volumetric measure that produces a volume of Pyrodex equal to the volume of a mass of 60 grains of black powder. Due to Pyrodex being less dense than black powder, a measurement of 60 grains of mass of Pyrodex would create an overload, if the Pyrodex were measured on a scale. Pyrodex is always measured in grains by a volumetric measurement technique, not by weight on a balance scale, due to the difference in density of Pyrodex vs. black powder. This primarily becomes an issue only while fabricating black powder cartridges through handloading if using a black powder substitute in place of black powder. With the increased safety of the black powder substitutes often comes a reduced sensitivity to ignition. Flintlocks in particular need very sensitive, finely granulated powder for use in the flash pan, and black powder tends to perform more reliably in these and traditional caplock guns than substitutes. Modern in-line muzzleloaders provide a stronger ignition than traditional designs, and this helps to increase reliability with the less sensitive substitutes. In addition, magnum percussion caps are often recommended for use with black powder substitutes for both inline and traditional caplock guns, in place of the non-magnum traditional percussion caps traditionally used with black powder in these guns, to achieve the best ignition reliability. Hodgdon's Pyrodex was the first widely available substitute on the market. Pyrodex is less sensitive than black powder, and uses the same shipping and storage guidelines as smokeless powder. Pyrodex is more powerful per unit of mass than black powder, but it is less dense, and can be substituted at a 1:1 ratio by volume for black powder in most applications. Pyrodex is similar in composition to black powder, consisting primarily ofcharcoal, sulfur, and potassium nitrate, but it also contains graphite and potassium perchlorate, plus additional ingredients protected by trade secret. Originally available as loose powder in two granularities, RS (Rifle/Shotgun) equal to FFG blackpowder, and P (Pistol) equal to FFFg blackpowder, Pyrodex is now becoming available in only Select and solid pellet varieties. While Pyrodex offers improved safety and increased efficiency (in terms of shots per pound of powder) over black powder, the level of fouling is similar.

Hodgdon also makes Triple Seven, one of the family of sulfurless black powder substitutes. Triple Seven and Black Mag3 are burn hotter than black powder, and produce higher velocities and pressures. Still burning carbon, the carbon-based fuel burned here is from the sugar family, not from charcoal.

Western Powders Company introduced Blackhorn 209 in 2008. Like other substitutes, it is made to be a volumetric equivalent of black powder. Blackhorn 209 is described as non-corrosive, low-fouling, very consistent in gas generation, and non-hygroscopic.







Storage Regulations have made Black power prices to skyrocket.



One should look at online sources to save money. Yes one should be aware of the transaction record keeping required of retailers.

Here is a partial list of retailers.

Powder Inc.

http://www.powderinc.com/

Please note that this retailer includes the HAZMAT fees in the price.



Graf & Sons

http://www.grafs.com/powders/3522



Magkor.com


http://www.magkor.com/Black_Powder.c...30%23714%23587





Additional information welcomed.